Close view of a brick home's covered entry, with a dark wood door, white-trimmed window, gray stone porch and burgundy oakleaf hydrangea.

Warrenton's Main Street Lost Its Summer. October Gets the Benefit.

Paving crews were still working on Main Street in Old Town Warrenton at about 6 a.m. on Friday, Sept. 25. The ribbon-cutting was set for 6 p.m. that same day. The rain delays and contractor problems had pushed the work to the deadline, but the street was finished in time. A few hundred people came downtown that night to celebrate.

From the trail access at Brookside Parkway and Boathouse Road, Main Street is about 7.6 miles and 13 minutes away by Route 605 and US-15/US-29. For six months, much of that short drive ended at closed sidewalks and a milled road surface. October is the first full month on the finished street. The fall calendar runs almost entirely along it, and the businesses that kept their doors open through the summer are in the middle of it.

What Was Actually Built

The project covered Main Street from Court Street to Fifth Street. The plan called for wider sidewalks, crosswalk bump-outs, new brick sidewalks, streetlight electrical upgrades, drainage work, and milling and repaving the whole street. Reporting after completion confirms the wider, replaced brick sidewalks and new brick-lined crosswalks. It also confirms larger outdoor dining areas from Culpeper Street to Second Street and a new pedestrian plaza on First Street.

The idea goes back to 2017. Mayor Carter Nevill and Town Manager Judson Rex both said the project took years and dealt with rising costs along the way. Construction started in March 2026. In August, FauquierNow reported that work had restarted on Aug. 10 after a month-long pause tied to the contractor, and that the street between Alexandria Pike and Fifth Street would be closed for crosswalk work through an expected Aug. 21 finish. The target date then moved from about Sept. 18 to the morning of the party itself.

Nevill explained the goal at the ceremony:

"We have just made the heart of our town of Warrenton a much more pedestrian and people-friendly place. We have put patrons first and put cars second."

He named the larger dining and gathering areas and the First Street plaza among the project's "greatest improvements."

What the Summer Cost the Block

The finished street was paid for in lost sales, and the Fauquier Times kept track of who paid them.

Frozen Yogi, at 11 Main Street, went more than 50 days of the summer without a sidewalk to its front door. Owners Sue Useem and Rob Sazegar said losing that access hurt their profits during their busiest season. At Cast Iron Craft House, owner Wesley Ross said equipment staged on Second Street made people think the restaurant had closed. He had no lunch customers on the first day of construction, and business fell 75% over the first three days.

Sandra Packwood moved Déjà Vu, her vintage clothing shop, from Main Street to Culpeper Street early in the summer to get away from the worst of the work. Parts of Culpeper Street ended up closing too, and her sales dropped to about half their usual level. "It was empty. It was dead. There was nobody here," she said of Main Street. She also said the sidewalk and crosswalk upgrades had to happen: "I tried to stay as positive as possible, because we needed to have it done."

Nevill said the heaviest work was put in August because it is usually the slowest month for downtown merchants. He also said the town lost time when its main paving contractor left for another job in the middle of the summer. "Lesson learned," he said.

These same businesses now have the wider sidewalks out front. One of them, Cast Iron Craft House, is on the October calendar for a reason that has nothing to do with lunch.

Where the New Sidewalk Space Went

The block from Culpeper Street to Second Street got the wider dining space, and the town tested the idea there first. In April 2025, FauquierNow covered a sidewalk-café trial on that block. A newly paved trial area outside Licorice Pizza served as the model for open-air seating on wider public sidewalks. First Street has a history as well. Back in November 2024, FauquierNow reported that Denim & Pearls had used First Street for extra seating while town officials talked about turning the space back to public use, with tables for gathering or room to walk. The finished plaza is the result of that discussion.

Experience Old Town Warrenton's directory lists these places in and around the rebuilt stretch:

  • Frozen Yogi, 11 Main Street
  • Deja Brew Cafe, 22 Main Street
  • Ellie's Place, 26 A Main Street, and E.B.'s BBQ, 26 B Main Street
  • Denim & Pearls, 29 Main Street, which lists indoor and outdoor patio seating
  • Licorice Pizza, 32 Main Street
  • Molly's Irish Pub, 36 Main Street, and Altered Suds Beer Company, 36 A Main Street

The shopping directory lists Blue Ridge Cyclery at 19 Main Street, which used to be The Bike Stop, and Britches Great Outdoors at 20 Main. It also lists Berkley Gallery at 40 Main, Carter & Spence at 41 Main, and 3 Sisters Boutique and The Lucky Knot, both at 44 Main. On the night of the party, the Fauquier Times reported that restaurants were mostly full of diners using the larger outdoor seating areas the new sidewalks made possible. How each restaurant sets up its outdoor tables from here on is still being worked out one block at a time.

A Brewery Back After 21 Months

On E. Lee Street in Old Town, a different downtown business is coming back on its own schedule. Silver Branch Warrenton Station, at 56 E. Lee St., holds its grand reopening Oct. 9 and 10. Friday runs 3 to 10 p.m., and Saturday runs 11:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. The brewery closed after an early-morning fire on Dec. 23, 2024, which caused severe damage to its kitchen and storage areas. Investigators traced the fire to an "accidental catastrophic electrical event" in the ceiling of the adjoining Fletching Building.

So in the space of about two weeks, downtown gets both its rebuilt Main Street and a brewery that has been closed for almost two years.

October Is Built Around the Street

Most of the fall calendar takes place on the new sidewalks or within a short walk of them. In date order:

  1. Oct. 9–10: Silver Branch grand reopening, 56 E. Lee St.
  2. Oct. 10: Paranormal investigation at the John Marshall Building, 32 Waterloo St., 6:30 to 9:30 p.m., run by Fauquier County Parks and Recreation.
  3. Oct. 18: Paranormal investigation at Cast Iron Craft House, 11 S. Second St., 6:30 to 9:30 p.m. This is the restaurant that lost three-quarters of its business during the first days of construction.
  4. Oct. 24: The Great Pumpkin Ride, a cycling event starting at the caboose on S. Fifth Street, with 24-, 44- and 62-mile route options.
  5. Oct. 30: Flashlight Candy Hunt at Rady Park, 6:45 to 7:45 p.m.
  6. Oct. 31: Halloween Parade on Main Street, 10 to 11 a.m. That afternoon, Trunk or Treat runs at the WARF and Warrenton Sports Complex from 2 to 4 p.m.
  7. Oct. 31: Halloween investigation at the Old Jail Museum, 6 to 9 p.m. It is included with the county's punch pass, and single-location passes aren't sold for this one.
  8. Nov. 7: Old Jail Museum investigation, 10 Ashby St., 6:30 to 9:30 p.m.
  9. Nov. 14: Investigation at a private Old Town residence, 6 to 9 p.m. The address goes to attendees after registration closes.

The Halloween Parade on Oct. 31 is scheduled on Main Street, so this year's parade route runs past the widened brick sidewalks.

The Saturday Routine, Through Nov. 22

The Warrenton farmers market runs every Saturday from 8 a.m. to noon at the public parking lots at Ashby and W. Lee streets until Nov. 22. That puts the market in Old Town itself, on the same Saturday mornings the rebuilt Main Street is open to walk.

If your Saturday usually includes the WARF, check before you go. The leisure pool and spa have been closed since Aug. 17 for replastering and the installation of a new Waterplay feature, and they're expected to reopen in early November. Water-fitness classes have moved to the competition pool for now.

On mornings when downtown can wait, the Brookside Trail is closer. The county describes it as a 5-mile route through the neighborhood, with trailheads at Brookside Parkway, Lake Brittle, Riley Road, Rogues Road and Shepherdstown Road. When the trail is done, Main Street is 13 minutes away, and the sidewalks are fully open for the first time since spring.

What's happening on Main Street this fall also matters to homeowners a few miles away. If you'd like to know how that factors into what your Brookside home is worth right now, The Eisenhard Group is glad to talk it through. Ask us for a home valuation, and we'll explain the local details that go into the number.

Work With Us

We strive to provide our clients with top-notch customer service. With four team members, rather than being spread thin, we have each utilized our strengths and skills to provide you with the best experience possible.

Follow Us on Instagram